Why Younger Americans Aren’t Buying the Patriot Myth: A Public Historian's Take

The Wall Street Journal poll revealing that younger Americans aren't especially "proud" of American history has sparked quite a buzz. But for those of us steeped in public history, it's hardly a revelation. Younger Americans are less enamored with our history than their elders. And before you jump to the conclusion that this is due to ignorance or apathy, let’s take a closer look.

I firmly believe that younger generations, particularly those from diverse backgrounds, are more knowledgeable about American history than their Baby Boomer counterparts. Their disillusionment isn't rooted in a lack of understanding but in a deeper, more critical comprehension of the past. This isn't about rejecting history; it's about rejecting the sanitized, glorified version that has long been the standard.

For decades, American history education has focused on hero-worship of the Founding Fathers, the triumphalism of Manifest Destiny, and a conspicuous silence on the brutal realities of slavery, genocide, and systemic oppression. This one-sided narrative was designed to instill pride and patriotism at the expense of truth.

Times have changed. Thanks to more honest and inclusive educational trends and the evolving field of public history, younger generations are learning a fuller, more nuanced version of American history. They’re being exposed to the dark chapters, the messy truths, and the ongoing struggles for justice and equality. And guess what? This reality isn't always something to be proud of.

But acknowledging the uncomfortable truths of our past is not only okay, it's essential. Public history isn't about blindly celebrating the past; it's about sparking honest conversations, challenging assumptions, and grappling with the complexities of our shared history. It's about using the past to understand our present and build a better future.

So, maybe younger Americans aren’t as proud of our history as older generations. That doesn't mean they don’t care. On the contrary, their critical perspective indicates a deeper engagement. They are asking tough questions, demanding accountability, and pushing for a more just and equitable society. They understand that true patriotism involves recognizing and addressing the flaws and failures of our past.

This is the power of public history. It’s not about regurgitating facts and figures; it’s about inspiring critical thinking, fostering empathy, and empowering people to make a difference in the world. We need to move beyond outdated narratives and embrace a more honest, inclusive, and engaging approach to public history.

Let's tell the stories that need to be told, even if they’re uncomfortable. Let’s use our voices, creativity, and digital platforms to spark conversations that can transform our understanding of the past and shape our future. Stay curious, stay critical, and above all, stay engaged.